Jun 15, 2015 what all these books to read if you like harry potter have in common is that they are page turners. Percy would win both rounds easy he could deflect the spells off the side of his. Harry just shouted and to me, that was like very immature and childish. I like kids books, in fact aside from classics, i only read kids books. Published in 1997, the first harry potter book, harry potter and the sorcerers stone, was quick to win the hearts of. Its perfectly fine if you prefer percy jackson over harry potter harry potter isnt for everyone. Feb 17, 2017 check out why harry potter is better than percy jackson 27. Numerous people have been influenced greatly by both novels. Add to library 73 discussion 48 browse more books tv. Top 10 reasons why percy jackson is not better than harry potter.
Both are very great books the percy jackson movies suck compared to the books i mean whats up with clarise not being in. These ads explain why books are always better than movies. Jackson, in a noholdsbarred magical deathmatch, would win over harry potter. This is like saying a doctor is not as smart as a rocket scientist. He has faults while harry was just too perfect having no family is not a fault percy even had a break down in the newest book. Percy jackson has five books excluding the olympians series in the. People in harry potters world want to build a new hogwarts right where camp halfblood is. Oct 10, 2016 percy jackson because harry potter is a nerd and is to scared to. The first few books of the harry potter series can be.
Percy jackson because harry potter is a nerd and is to scared to. We have detailed information including the percy jackson and the olympians books series, the heroes of olympus book series, the. This time, its the characters and places for two of the most bestselling series percy jackson and harry potter. Oct 10, 2010 but there is books like harry potter, spiderwick chronicless, percy jackson and the olympians, the kane cronicles, fablehaven, and the chronicles of narnia. Who would win in a fight between percy jackson and harry potter. Are percy jackson books better than harry potter books. Percy jackson and the team were having an okay day at camp. She doesnt have anything going for her in a fight to the death like this. I recommend these books to read if you like harry potter for independent readers, ages 10 and up, but of. I like percy jackson better because im more into gods and.
Can killstun someone by using the water in their body can heal truly fast in water can control all versions of water i. If there was a desert fight, harry would win for sure. Hogwarts had almost every wizards gathered, though camp halfblood has aids of gods, demigods and magicians. Who would win in a fight between percy jackson and harry. Hogwarts had almost every wizards gathered, though camp halfblood has aids of. If there was an underwater fight, percy would win for sure. Aug 15, 2011 i like both, but harry potter wins for me. Why does maggots like to stay on animals open wounds. Although i personally believe harry potter would win, i decided to try and practice defending a side i wouldnt normally support. The books describe percy as having dyslexia and adhd courtesy of his. You have to read all of the percy jackson books they are amazing.
And according to standard battle assumptions, the starting location of the fight is central park, new. I like the writing style more and i like how when you reread it you notice different stuff so its interesting every time you read it. Dec 08, 2012 if you havent read both series, dont answer please. Published in 1997, the first harry potter book, harry. Who would win in a fight harry potter or percy jackson. First of all, lets just assume this is a fight to the death, and both of them want to kill each other. Both novels are similar, yet with slight differences. Since harry potter is longer, that usually means it is better.
Test your knowledge on this literature quiz to see how you do and compare your score to others. It is fruitless to say that harry potter isnt as good as percy jackson. There job done like how hard is it hary is a very powerfull wizard and all percy jackson is is a. Percy jackson random literature or harry potter quiz. The harry potter series also happens to have a darker tone, especially in the later books. Can you name the harry potter vs percy jackson things. He came across a new place he had never been before.
Books written like that arent usually as funny as first person books, like percy jackson. Between the two men which one do you mostly identify with. So there you have it, my analysis of harry potter vs. Harry potter is better than percy jackson because the harry potter books are longer than the percy jackson books. Top 10 reasons why percy jackson is not better than harry. If we are talking about the books for harry, than yes, harry potter is in for the win, but if it is the book pj and movie hp, than percy jackson wins.
Just like harry potter, percy too found out he has special abilities, and that. Harry potter borders more on an epic mystery, which percy jackson is limited to being a middlegrade action adventure. Percy jackson is good, but i feel like it lacks the subtleties and connections throughout the whole series that harry potter has. Harry potter, for instance, is written in third person limited. The debate has been going on for almost fifteen years. Harry potter and a few friends are just investigating a mysterious figurine. Aug 09, 2018 harry potter borders more on an epic mystery, which percy jackson is limited to being a middlegrade action adventure. Dont just stick to your favorite series even though you like the other choice better.
As far as teenage readers can remember, there have always been big debates about what literary series are better than others. Aug 06, 2011 can you name the similarities between harry potter and percy jackson. Percy, annabeth, and gover or harry, ron, and hermione. I recommend these books to read if you like harry potter for independent readers, ages 10 and up, but of course every reader is different, so use your best judgement. The first few books of the harry potter series can be classified as middlegrade fantasies. For example, in book two in percy jackson and the olympiansthe sea of monsters, in the movie, the titan lord kronos rises. I can bend your blood and enforce my will upon yours during a full moon. Potatoes are awesome, i read all harry potter books and percy jackson books.
When i asked him for further details, he maintained that the plot of all the series was essentially the same except that instead of greek mythology the books take place in norse, egyptian and roman mythological worlds, respectively. Mar, 2018 as far as teenage readers can remember, there have always been big debates about what literary series are better than others. I grew up loving the animorphs series, and ill admit ive recently fallen back on more comfortable novels, like lord of the rings, harry potter, asimovs robots, empire, and foundation series, but there are still things to be learned and new. Although the percy jackson universe and the harry potter universe have different rules and from them to clash wouldnt make sense.
Howd you get katniss everdeen, harry potter, percy jackson, and. Rowling for creating the amazing world of harry potter. Can you name the similarities between harry potter and percy jackson. Both story ideas are incredible, but harry potter takes the win for this. Harry potter vs percy jackson vs battles wiki fandom. In an earlier article, we analyzed percy jackson and harry potter strictly from. Harry potter, percy jackson, jason grace, or edward. In the end id say harry potter because the books are longer and there are more of them. As such percy jackson a demigod with godly reflexes who can dodge and block bullets at point blank range. I grew up loving the animorphs series, and ill admit ive recently fallen back on more comfortable novels, like lord of the rings, harry potter, asimovs robots, empire, and foundation series, but there are still things to be learned and new perspectives to view in these books. The lightning thief similiaraties between harry potter and. Who do you all like better annabeth chase or hermione. Ive had a discussion with my brother whether several pjo and hp characters would win in a fight, for example, of course percy vs. This is like saying a doctor is not as smart as a rocket scientist because heshe doesnt understand how rockets work.
Who do you all like better annabeth chase or hermione granger. Dont get me wrong in a fight percy and co might be able to beat harry and co but it would take longer, it would be a longer and harder fight, and not all harry potter characters would lose to the percy jackson characters. They never thought theyd end up in another country. What is better harry potter or percy jackson and the. However, there is no denying that harry potter is a better series. If your kids like percy jackson, they are sure to like the authors other series. Countless individuals have been reading and obsessing over the famous series and still do to this day. Do you think percy jackson would win a fight against harry potter. The lightning thief whos more famous, percy or harry. If you havent read both series, dont answer please. This time, its the characters and places for two of the most bestselling seriespercy jackson and harry potter. Here are the book addicted girls top recommended books for people who love harry potter and are in need of their next magic fix. Do voldemort and harry fight in the book harry potter and the order of phoenix. Jackson, in a no holdsbarred magical deathmatch, would win over harry potter.
I love both of the books and have read the main series of both. What to read after harry potter childrens books the. But percy jackson is not harry potter, nor is harry potter where the ideas originated. Harry potter vs percy jackson battle arena youtube. In my opinion both characters are brave, intelligent and loyal. Pov harry potter was walking through the forbidden forest with his usual group, ron and hermione. People in harry potter s world want to build a new hogwarts right where camp halfblood is.
What all these books to read if you like harry potter have in common is that they are page turners. Another reason harry potter is better than percy jackson is that the percy jackson movies are nothing like the book. Harry potter and percy jackson have a lot of things in common such as being powerful and never knowing to both having movie sequels that were top in the box office. Would be more than able to evade every single one of harrys spells. In the sense that i am working with the same patterns, toying with the same mythology, doing variations on the same centuriesold themes yes. They would be more like a corner cut off the edge of the cover of the book. But harry potter is far more widely know then percy jackson.
Check out why harry potter is better than percy jackson 27. If you have not finished both series, dont answer or read. If you could have percy jackson adapted in to a tvmovie what would it be like. If one harry potter character could be friends with one rick riordan character, who would it be and why. He often comes across as dull when compared to characters like hermione, ron and neville who all have their. While demigods tries to defend the only place on earth that is safe for them.
It seems that one of the biggest debates in our generation specifically, is the debate between harry potter and percy jackson, and for good reason. There was a river that was too deep to walk across. Percy can use his powers anytime, but harry needs a wand and a. After reading harry potter, people may think it would be hard to top a series like that. I have read all five pjo books, and obviously all seven harry potter books. See more ideas about percy jackson, harry potter and jackson. Maybe youll never find a book better than harry potter, but that doesnt mean you cant enjoy reading other novels about magic, friendship. You guys obviously lost your mind if you think harry is gonna win. Theyre also in an inescapable arena, with no lakes, oceans, or objects. Im a huge fan of the series and enjoy everything percy jackson related. I would say that harry potter is way more famous then percy jackson. Percy vs harry chapter 1, a percy jackson and the olympians.
705 1308 996 124 1381 177 86 1165 818 142 489 704 959 1307 1247 1271 24 964 757 182 686 892 226 1490 811 1023 158 845 165 988 13